When choosing a fly fishing landing net for trout catch and release, the key considerations are mesh type (soft rubber vs. big mesh), net size, and fish-friendly design to minimize harm to the fish. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:
1. Soft Rubber Mesh vs. Big (Knotless) Mesh
-
Soft Rubber Mesh (Best for Catch & Release)
- Pros:
- Gentle on fish slime and scales (reduces injury).
- Tangles hooks less (easier release).
- Lightweight and dries quickly.
- Cons:
- Slightly heavier when wet than nylon.
- Smaller mesh may hold water, adding weight.
- Pros:
-
Big/Knotless Nylon Mesh
- Pros:
- Drains water faster (lighter when lifting fish).
- Larger openings reduce drag in current.
- Cons:
- Can still harm trout’s protective slime if abrasive.
- Higher hook-snagging risk.
- Pros:
Winner for Trout C&R: Soft rubber mesh (prioritizes fish safety).
2. Net Size & Shape
- Small Nets (12"–15" hoop)
- Ideal for small streams or tiny trout.
- Lightweight and maneuverable.
- Large Nets (16"–20" hoop, deeper bag)
- Better for big trout (e.g., 20"+ fish).
- More forgiving when scooping.
Tip: A teardrop or rectangular shape offers better control than round nets.
3. Other Features for Trout
- Shallow Bag Depth: Prevents over-handling fish.
- Non-Reflective Colors (black/green): Less spooky to trout.
- Lightweight Frame: Carbon fiber or aluminum.
Top Recommendations
- Fishpond Nomad Emerger (soft rubber, eco-friendly, mid-size).
- Rising Rubber Mesh Net (affordable, fish-safe).
- Frabill Trout Landing Net (big mesh option for quick drainage).
Final Verdict
For catch-and-release trout fishing, a soft rubber mesh net (medium size, ~16" hoop) is ideal. If you fish in fast currents or target larger trout, a big knotless mesh can work but requires extra care handling fish.
Would you like recommendations based on specific trout species (e.g., brook vs. rainbow)?